The 2026 American Midterm Elections have been completed, and the Democratic Party has succeeded in winning control of both Houses of Congress, by a wide margin. This is to say that the Democrats will soon have a comfortable majority in the Senate and the House of Representatives, as soon as the newly elected Members are sworn in, on January 3.
This is significant, because the Utopian Socialists, led by Senator Bernie Sanders, are convinced that this provides an opportunity for the ‘’progressive forces’’, led by the Democratic Socialists of America, the DSA, to enact some ‘’meaningful reforms’’. They are convinced that they have an opportunity to dramatically raise the standard of living of the working people of America, as well as restoring their democratic rights.
Senator Sanders laid this out quite clearly, immediately after the conclusion of the Midterm Elections. He stated this in a video titled ‘’Bernie Explains Whats Next After the Midterms’’. I have chosen to transcribe the pertinent parts:
‘’We are living in an unprecedented moment in American history, where our country faces extraordinary crises. …These crises must be dealt with….People are giving up on democracy….working families are struggling to put food on the table, and pay for basic necessities, while the very richest people become much richer….The American people have had enough….They are demanding real change and bold policies that will dramatically improve their lives….The American people want a government that stands for working families, not billionaire contributors….According to a recent AP poll, 80% of registered voters want either ‘complete and total upheaval, or substantial change in how this country is run’….The American people want change, real change….. Income and wealth inequality has reached unprecedented levels….We must take on the greed of the very, very rich, and their incredible wealth. And that means a Democratic Congress must pass a wealth tax on billionaires….We must enact a 5% wealth tax on billionaires, so that we can provide every working class family in the country, a family of four, with a $12,000 dollar direct payment….Furthermore, with that tax on billionaires, we can build 7 million units of low income and affordable housing. We can make public colleges and universities tuition free, and we can provide universal, free child care for 13 million children. That is what a wealth tax on billionaires can do. But taxing the Oligarchs means more than just taking on their wealth. It means ending their strangle hold, over our political system….Democracy must mean one person, one vote, not billionaires buying elections. …Everybody understands that our health care system is broken, it is dysfunctional, it is wildly expensive….More than 90 million Americans are uninsured or under insured. Over half a million people go bankrupt each year, because of medial debt. …more than 60,000 Americans die unnecessarily every year, because they cannot afford medical care….Health care must be considered as a human right, not a privilege….The $7.25 federal minimum wage is a starvation wage. Democrats must raise it to a living wage of at least 20 bucks an hour, and make it easier for workers to form unions….We must also restore the traditional pension plans corporate America took away, so that every worker can count on a guaranteed income in retirement. …Trump has dragged us into an illegal and unconstitutional war in Iran…We must end this disastrous war. We must cut off all funding for the genocidal government in Israel, and we must substantially reduce military spending. …ICE agents have shot American citizens in cold blood, have broken down doors to arrest people, and have sent five year old children to detention centres. These actions are not only immoral and disgraceful, they are unconstitutional….We must finally move to comprehensive immigration reform, and a path towards citizenship for the undocumented. …We are in a moment in American history, where a lot of folks are losing faith in democracy. They are struggling every day just to stay alive, while at the same time, billionaires have more money than they can spend in a thousand lifetimes, and are getting richer and richer all of the time…We are fighting to give hope to the American people to allow them to understand that in fact their government can work for them, can address the crises that they face, and will pay attention to the needs of the men, women and children in our country, who are struggling, and not just the very, very wealthy campaign contributors. That is, in my view, what Democrats have got to do, when they assume power in January.’’
To this I can only respond that Senator Bernie Sanders has given us a rather detailed, accurate description, of our current situation. America is indeed facing ‘’extraordinary crises’’, in both an economic and a political sense, as he has documented. He is also correct when he says that ‘’a lot of folks are losing faith in democracy’’. Yet it is also true that there are a great many people who still have faith in democracy.
For that reason, may I suggest that all progressive people, and not just Scientific Socialists, enthusiastically support Senator Bernie Sanders and his followers, those who refer to themselves as ‘’Bernie Bros’’, in their quest to ‘’give hope to the American people’’, to ‘’understand that in fact their government can work for them’’, and ‘’will pay attention to the needs of the men, women and children in our country, who are struggling’’. This is the goal which Sanders has laid out, for the Democrats, ‘’when they assume power in January’’.
That is certainly a ‘’tall order’’, but ‘’in theory’’, it can be done. I deliberately placed those words in italics, because in fact, it absolutely cannot be done! This calls for a little explanation.
Congress certainly has the authority to impose a ‘’5% wealth tax on billionaires’’, and such a tax would dramatically increase the living standards for countless working class Americans. It is the Constitution which grants the House of Representatives this power. Yet having this power is one thing, and using this power, is something else entirely.
As Scientific Socialists, we can state as a fact, that the revolutionary theories of Marx and Lenin are absolutely correct. We live in a class society! For that reason, there is a constant class struggle going on between the ruling class of monopoly capitalists, the multi billionaires, currently referred to as the ‘’Oligarchy’’, technically referred to as the bourgeoisie, and the working class, technically referred to as the proletariat. This class struggle occasionally breaks out into open class warfare! Also in technical jargon, this class warfare is referred to as a revolution! We are very close to that point, the Second American Revolution! It is the existence of classes, and especially the class struggle, which necessarily leads to a revolution, which the Utopian Socialists generally avoid, or at best, gloss over!
As I have documented in a previous article, the House of Representatives and the Senate, are part of the ‘’state apparatus’’, which has been set up by the ruling class of monopoly capitalists, with the sole purpose of crushing and exploiting the ‘’lower classes’’, and in particular the working class. There is no way on ‘’God’s green earth’’, that the multi billionaires are about to allow that same state apparatus, their state apparatus, to be used against them! That is not about to happen!
As far as the multi billionaires are concerned, the Constitution is a mere scrap of paper! To be used when it is convenient, and disregarded when it is not. It is absolutely not convenient to have a ‘’wealth tax’’ placed on them!
As well, we would be the last people to argue over the necessity to ‘’end the stranglehold of the Oligarchy over our political system’’, to ‘’restore democracy’’ in the form of ‘’one person, one vote, not billionaires buying elections’’.
Allow me to add that ‘’restoring democracy’’, as Sanders phrased it, is a simple matter of enforcing the laws which exist, as laid out in the Constitution. Further, as each and every federal official has taken an oath to ‘’preserve, protect and defend the Constitution’’, it is their duty to do just that. Not that it matters! This too is a mere ‘’inconvience’’, not allowed under the rule of the Oligarchy!
This is my less than subtle way of saying that Sanders and his followers, the ‘’Bernie Bros’’, have about as much chance of achieving these ‘’noble objectives’’, as a rabbit has of surviving in a wolf den! Yet in the process of making the attempt, countless working people, who still have faith in the democratic republic, will become convinced of the correctness of Scientific Socialism.
In the interests of drawing a clear distinction between Scientific Socialism and Utopian Socialism, may I refer you to the web site of the DSA, in which they lay out their political platform:
‘’Who we are:
‘’The Democratic Socialists of America is the largest socialist organization in the United States, with over 100,000 members and chapters in all 50 states. We believe that working people should run both the economy and society democratically to meet human needs, not to make profits for a few.
‘’What we do
‘’We are a political and activist organization, not a party; through campus and community-based chapters, DSA members use a variety of tactics, from legislative to direct action, to fight for reforms that empower working people.’’
Allow me to stress the fact that the members of the DSA are Socialists in name only! They are fighting strictly for democracy and reforms! This is characteristic of most, if not all, Utopian Socialists. Perhaps they think that if enough reforms are enacted, monopoly capitalism will gradually be transformed into a state of socialism. Now that is a happy thought!
This stands in stark contrast to Scientific Socialism, which is based upon the revolutionary theories of two great social scientists, Marx and Lenin. It was Marx who studied capitalism in the mid to late nineteenth century, at a time when capitalism was in its early, competitive, pre monopoly stage. As well, Lenin studied capitalism in the early twentieth century, at the time it reached the stage of monopoly, referred to as imperialism, at least in Western Europe. The conclusions they reached, as a result of these thorough investigations, are referred to as the theories of Scientific Socialism.
Marx spelled this out quite clearly, in his letter to Weydemeyer, in 1852. As he stated:
‘’And now as to myself, no credit is due to me for discovering the existence of classes in modern society, nor yet the struggle between them. Long before me, bourgeois historians had described the historical development of this class struggle, and bourgeois economists the economic anatomy of the classes. What I did that was new was to prove: 1) that the existence of classes is only bound up with particular historical phases in the development of production; 2) that the class struggle necessarily leads to the Dictatorship of the Proletariat; 3) that this Dictatorship itself only constitutes the transition to the abolition of all classes and to a classless society.’’ (my italics)
Even the ‘’bourgeois historians’’ acknowledge the ‘’existence of classes’’, as well as the ‘’struggle between them’’. It is our modern day Utopian Socialists, who gloss over the existence of classes, while failing to acknowledge the class struggle! They certainly make no mention of the fact that this class struggle necessarily leads to the Dictatorship of the Proletariat!
It was Lenin who first faced this problem, in the early twentieth century. Bear in mind that, at that time, Scientific Socialism was referred to as ‘’Social Democracy’’. He documented his differences with the Utopian Socialists, in his article, What Is To Be Done? Lenin:
‘’Social Democracy must change from a party of the social revolution, into a democratic party of social reform. Bernstein has surrounded this political demand with a whole battery of systematically arranged ‘new’ arguments and reasonings. The possibility of putting socialism on a scientific basis, and of proving that it is necessary and inevitable, from the point of view of the materialist conception of history was denied, as also were the facts of the growing impoverishment and proletarianization, and the intensification of capitalist contradictions. The very conception, ‘ultimate aim’, was declared to be unsound, and the idea of the Dictatorship of the Proletariat, was absolutely rejected. It was denied that there is any difference in principle between liberalism and socialism. The theory of the class struggle was rejected, on the grounds that it could not be applied to a strictly democratic society, governed according to the will of the majority, etc.’’ (italics by Lenin)
There can be no doubt that our current crop of ‘’Social Democrats’’, in the form of the DSA, are of the same opinion, even though they do not express themselves in those precise terms. Yet that in no way changes the fact that we should support them, in their efforts to ‘’change the system from within’’, as the capitalists phrase it.
As these well meaning individuals, Utopian Socialists, make a supreme effort to do just that, the working people will receive a valuable education. The ‘’Oligarchy’’ will make it clear, one way or another, that they are in charge, and fully intend to remain in charge. They will ‘’show their true colours’’!
At that point, all working people, and not just the most advanced, will realize that the Scientific Socialists are correct, that the ruling class of monopoly capitalists has to be overthrown, the existing state apparatus must be smashed, and replaced, with a new state apparatus, in the form of Soviet Power and the Dictatorship of the Proletariat! That is true Scientific Socialism, true democracy, for the working class, one person, one vote!
That is the reason we must offer our most emphatic support for Sanders and the other Utopian Socialists. The working class must become aware, from their own experience, of the correctness of the revolutionary theories, of Marx and Lenin. There is no other way.
With Most Sincere Scientific Socialist Greetings,
Gerald McIsaac